Compelling Evidence 3.0 wants two prior undisputed transactions 120–365 days old on the same credential; a BFCM first-timer has zero. When history is unavailable the case rests on what you captured at the moment of purchase: device and IP consistency, AVS on billing, 3DS where applied, and an unbroken delivery chain to the address the cardholder supplied. That makes order-time capture non-optional for peak, because none of it can be reconstructed from a two-month-old order record.
Why CE 3.0 goes quiet
CE 3.0 is the strongest tool against 10.4 friendly fraud, and its qualifying conditions are specific: at least two prior transactions on the same credential, undisputed, between 120 and 365 days before the disputed one. A customer whose first order with you was Black Friday fails that test by definition, and will keep failing it until late March.
So for the January dispute wave on BFCM orders, expect CE 3.0 to be available on your returning cohort and unavailable on the surge. Plan the evidence strategy around that split rather than discovering it per case.
What substitutes for history
With no prior relationship, the rebuttal is built entirely from the transaction itself:
- Billing AVS result — a full match on the billing address is the single most useful signal you have on a first order.
- 3DS outcome where it was applied, including whether liability shifted.
- Device and IP consistent with the billing geography.
- Delivery to the cardholder-specified address, with the scan or signature.
- Post-purchase engagement: tracking emails opened, the order status page viewed, support contact. Someone who tracked the parcel knew about the order.
That last group is routinely forgotten and routinely persuasive. All of it has to be captured at order time — email engagement and device data are not sitting in the order record in February. For Shopify orders, Aurai pulls the browser IP, device details and delivery tracking that Shopify stored with the order into the response automatically. Email and tracking-page engagement are not in the order record, so those you have to keep yourself.
Frequently asked questions
Can I use CE 3.0 on a first-time customer?
No. It requires at least two prior undisputed transactions on the same credential, 120–365 days old. A new customer cannot qualify until that history exists.
What is the best evidence against fraud claims on a first order?
Billing AVS match, 3DS result, device and IP consistency with billing, delivery proof to the specified address, and evidence the buyer engaged with post-purchase emails or tracking.
Post reflects public documentation and industry surveys as of the publish date. Win rates and other figures are indicative ranges, not guarantees and not Aurai results; outcomes vary by merchant, evidence, and issuer. Visa, Mastercard, American Express, Discover, Stripe, PayPal, and Shopify are trademarks of their respective owners; Aurai is independent and not endorsed by any of them. Network rules change — always verify current official rules before acting on any specific tactic.