The alert decision is arithmetic — refund cost versus dispute cost times loss probability — and at volume it must be pre-computed into thresholds rather than decided case by case. Write the rule in November: auto-refund below a value where fighting never pays, auto-refund any case with weak evidence regardless of value, and reserve human judgement for high-value orders with strong delivery proof. An unanswered alert is the worst outcome, because you pay the alert fee and get the chargeback anyway.
The arithmetic
Refunding on alert costs the goods, the shipping and the alert fee. Letting it become a chargeback costs the goods, the shipping, the dispute fee, staff time, and a point on your dispute rate — multiplied by your probability of losing.
So the comparison is: refund cost, versus dispute cost × P(loss). With a typical dispute fee and a realistic win rate on friendly fraud, refunding wins outright below a threshold that is higher than most merchants assume. Above it, strong evidence can justify the fight — but only where the evidence actually exists, which on a two-month-old gift order is less often than you would hope. The alert economics post works the numbers; this one is about applying them at speed.
Writing the rule
Four buckets, decided now:
- Auto-refund, any value — no delivery proof, delivery to a reshipper, a genuine service failure, or an order you would concede anyway.
- Auto-refund below threshold — where the dispute fee alone approaches the order value, fighting is theatre.
- Human review — high value with a clean delivery scan, signature, or an authenticated account history.
- Never ignore. An expired alert is the only outcome with no upside at all.
Then staff bucket 3 specifically. At peak the volume of alerts in buckets 1 and 2 will swamp a queue that treats everything as a judgement call, and the casualties are the bucket-3 cases that were worth real attention. Aurai records each Ethoca, Verifi and Stripe early-fraud alert as it arrives, so the queue you triage is complete — the refund decision itself stays yours, made in your own Stripe or Shopify admin, which is why the thresholds need writing down.
Frequently asked questions
Should I refund every chargeback alert?
Close to it below a value threshold, because the dispute fee plus loss probability usually exceeds the refund. Above that threshold it depends on whether you hold real delivery evidence.
What happens if I ignore an alert?
You pay the alert fee and still receive the chargeback. It is strictly worse than either refunding or preparing a defence.
Post reflects public documentation and industry surveys as of the publish date. Win rates and other figures are indicative ranges, not guarantees and not Aurai results; outcomes vary by merchant, evidence, and issuer. Visa, Mastercard, American Express, Discover, Stripe, PayPal, and Shopify are trademarks of their respective owners; Aurai is independent and not endorsed by any of them. Network rules change — always verify current official rules before acting on any specific tactic.