Home › Blog › Furniture chargebacks — oversized delivery disputes
Shopify

Furniture chargebacks — oversized delivery disputes

Parcel disputes are won with a tracking number. Freight disputes are lost with one, because LTL carriers do not produce the thing issuers have been trained to look for.

Published November 14, 2026 · 5 min read
Start free — pay per win →

Oversized delivery breaks the standard evidence template: no granular tracking, delivery appointments instead of dates, and a bill of lading rather than a scan. The three recurring fights are not-received on a delivered pallet, damage discovered after the driver leaves, and refused delivery billed as non-delivery. Each needs different paperwork, and all of it has to be captured at delivery time — reconstructing a freight delivery eight weeks later is close to impossible.

The evidence gap

An issuer analyst reviewing a 13.1 is looking for a carrier scan showing delivery to the billing or shipping address. Freight gives you a signed bill of lading, a delivery receipt with a timestamp, and sometimes a photograph — all legitimate, none in the format the reviewer expects.

So the submission has to do translation work the parcel case does not. Lead with a plain statement of what the document is: "Delivery receipt signed by the recipient at the shipping address on 14 December at 10:42, carrier [name], PRO number [x] — the freight equivalent of a parcel delivery scan." Attach the signed BOL, the appointment confirmation showing the recipient chose the window, and any driver photograph.

The three fights

  • Not received, but delivered. Signed delivery receipt plus the appointment trail. The appointment matters because it proves the recipient was expecting it and agreed the slot — much harder to argue around than a doorstep drop, and stronger than signature confirmation alone.
  • Damage found after the driver leaves. This becomes 13.3 defective rather than non-delivery. Your defence is the delivery receipt noting condition at handover. If your carrier's receipt has a damage checkbox and nobody ticks it, that box is your evidence — train the process to use it.
  • Refusal billed as non-delivery. A refused delivery is documented by the carrier. That document plus your return policy reframes the case from "never arrived" to "declined at the door", which is a return dispute with different rules.

Capture all of it at delivery, the same discipline as order-time evidence capture. Aurai pulls fulfilment records into the dispute automatically, but it can only submit documents that exist — a BOL nobody scanned is not evidence.

Frequently asked questions

Is a signed bill of lading enough to win a non-delivery dispute?

Usually, provided the submission explains what it is. Reviewers are trained on parcel scans, so a BOL presented without translation can be read as unrelated paperwork.

Who is liable when freight arrives damaged?

Commercially it depends on your carrier terms, but for the dispute what matters is the condition noted on the delivery receipt at handover. An unmarked receipt supports your position.

Post reflects public documentation and industry surveys as of the publish date. Win rates and other figures are indicative ranges, not guarantees and not Aurai results; outcomes vary by merchant, evidence, and issuer. Visa, Mastercard, American Express, Discover, Stripe, PayPal, and Shopify are trademarks of their respective owners; Aurai is independent and not endorsed by any of them. Network rules change — always verify current official rules before acting on any specific tactic.

Automate your chargeback response

Aurai reads every dispute, assembles the right evidence, and submits before the deadline. Pay 25% only on wins.

Start free →